Italy's PM under fire from allies over budget
By Silvia Ognibene, Reuters
October 15, 2012, 5:09 pm TWN
PRATO, Italy -- The parties that support Italian Prime Minister Mario Monti's unelected government demanded changes to his budget on Saturday, saying it would hurt households already suffering from austerity measures.
Although proposals announced on Wednesday included a tax cut for low earners, they also included a rise in value added tax and limits on other tax breaks as Monti tries to bring public finances under control to avoid a Greek-style debt crisis.
Whether or not the measures in the 2013-2015 budget would mean more belt-tightening overall is unclear. But with parties gearing up for a parliamentary election in six months, they did not hold back in criticizing the plans.
“There are many things that must be changed,” Angelino Alfano, secretary of the People of Liberty party, told a conference in Tuscany. “First and foremost, the value added tax increase must be eliminated. It's not tolerable that a VAT hike gobbles up the small benefit of the income-tax cut.”
The other two main parties supporting Monti also called for changes. There was no sign they would withdraw their support for Monti, but any changes to appease them would make it harder to meet Monti's target for cutting the deficit.
Stefano Fassina, economic adviser for the Democratic Party, said further spending cuts to schools and health care are not acceptable and that the budget needs “significant changes.” The Union of the Center party, led by Pier Ferdinando Casini, criticized the retroactive elimination of income tax breaks.
A draft of the spending bill says the new rules will be applied to 2012 taxes, which are paid next year. The budget still has to be presented to parliament.
Monti, who took power in November with a pledge to avert a catastrophic debt crisis, has not ruled out changes to the spending law in parliament, but has repeatedly said the public account targets are sacrosanct.
Tax Increase or Decrease?
The 1-percentage-point VAT increase will bring in more than 3 billion euros next year and more than 6.5 billion euros in 2014, according to a budget draft, which will not be sent in its final form to parliament until next week.
Meanwhile, the income tax cuts of one percentage point for the two lowest tax brackets would cut revenue by 5.5 billion euros, Economy Minister Vittorio Grilli said on Friday.
But opponents of the measures say the impact of the value added tax increase and limit on tax breaks would be greater than the income tax cut.
“In reality, there is a tax increase even with a one point cut to income taxes,” said Susanna Camusso, head of Italy's largest union, the CGIL, which threatened to call a general strike after the budget was presented on Wednesday.
Austerity measures imposed by Monti to try to bring public finances under control have exacerbated a yearlong recession in the euro zone's third-biggest economy and have been a focus of criticism from all political factions.
Monti, who took over from Silvio Berlusconi amid a dire financial crisis, has ruled out running in next year's election, but has said he would be available to serve again if Italy's fractious political parties are unable to form a government.
The government forecasts Italy's economy will contract by 2.4 percent in 2012 and 0.2 percent in 2013, and the public deficit is expected to hit 2.6 percent of gross domestic product before narrowing to 1.8 percent in 2013.
A Reuters poll of more than 20 economists this week forecast a contraction of 0.7 percent next year, a deeper recession than the government expects.